Victoria Batstone
Make an enquiry
Date Published:10 Mar 2016 Last Updated:18 Jan 2022

The High Court orders the return of a child back to Japan for the first time under the Hague Convention

Family Law

The UK High Court has ordered the return of a 7 year old Japanese child, following the mother’s wrongful retention of the child in the UK. This is the first time that a child has been ordered to return to Japan since Japan became the 91st country to become a signatory to The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction in April 2014. The Hague Convention requires its signatories to promptly return children who have been abducted by a parent to another signatory state/country, unless one of three defences is successfully raised. The main thrust of the Convention is to restore the status quo so that decisions concerning a child’s future are by made by the Court in their home country.

According to The Japan Times, the Mother moved to the UK with the child for work purposes. The Father understood that this would be for a period of 4 weeks only. When the Mother and child did not return as agreed, the Father made an urgent application to the UK’s International Central Authority for Child Abduction for the return of the child. On 22nd July 2014, the High Court ordered the return of the child, finding that the Mother wrongfully retained the child in the UK.

Japan’s decision to become a signatory to the Hague Convention is a welcome one. Japan’s previous reluctance to join the Convention attracted much criticism from other Hague Convention countries as the Japanese Courts were seen to favour Japanese nationals, particularly mothers, in international children disputes. The lawyer representing the Applicant Father told The Japan Times that he welcomes the judgement and said that “[w]ithout The Hague Convention, I believe that the way to raise the child [would be] by the mother’s decision”. It remains to be seen whether the mother will seek permission from the Japanese Court to move the child permanently to the UK.